Government Officials Dispel Misinformation on the oil & mineral exploration efforts in Somaliland at the Forum
By Goth Mohamed Goth
A one day extractive sector national forum was today hosted by Somaliland non state actor (SONSAF) extensively covered all areas that need to be exhausted before engaging in the exploration and production of oil and gases in the country.
Mr. Mohamed Mahmoud AKA Barwani, the executive secretary of Somaliland non state actor forum (SONSAF) in his opening statement at the one extractive sector national forum said,”Honorable ministers, members from EU, UN, International Organizations, Civil Society, Business sector, Universities, intellectuals, Traditional elders and community based organizations, ladies and gentle men good morning. It is great pleasure for civil society and non state actors of Somaliland to have here with you today, special thanks to the Minister of Energy and Minerals Hussein Abdi Dualeh and Minister of Interior Ali Mohamed Arwancadde for their dedication and acceptance to appear in front of the civil society, non state actors and wider stakeholders.
Today, it is a great opportunity for the non state actors in Somaliland to organize this event which will be extensively discussed the Extractive sector in Somaliland; civil society and non state actor are committed to maximize their level of engagement on issues of natural resources management, transparent and accountability.
One of the main objectives of this forum is create an acceptable environment that non state actors and state actors can interact and have a meaningful dialogue and timely information sharing through coherent and regular coordination. Non state actors of Somaliland are heart of the socio-economic and political process and they are advocating the public participation, proper resource management, accountability, freedom of expression, decentralization, peace- building and democratic institution to function across.
Since the natural resources are the central premises for the violent conflict and instability in many parts of Africa, civil society and non state actors of Somaliland have some cautions and analytical measures, in order to prevent any potential conflict that may arise such exploration and extracting the natural resources of the country. The exploitation of the non-renewable natural resources, including oil, gas, minerals and timber has often been cited as a key factor accelerating and escalating or sustaining violent conflict around the globe. Against this background, it is imperative to undertake some coherent and comprehensive measures through structured stakeholders’ engagement.
Eventually, civil society and non state actors in Somaliland are dedicated to promote positive social changes, mitigating risks and encouraging international investors, in order to improve the livelihood of the people, employability and economic development, managing natural resources is one of most the critical challenges facing developing countries across.
Mr. Mohamed Mahmoud AKA Barwani, the executive secretary of Somaliland non state actor forum (SONSAF) speaking at the one extractive sector national forum
Somaliland Minister of Energy and Minerals Hon Hussein Abdi Dualeh speaking at the one day forum said, “Somaliland will aspire to manage its resources in a sustainable and responsible way and would like to emulate countries which have done an excellent job of managing their hydrocarbon resources for the benefit of its people.
On behalf of the Ministry of Energy and Minerals thanked for SONSAF for hosting the one day forum meant to dispel public fears and the misinformation on the country’s oil activates and he went on to reiterate government commitment on transparency by stating, Our goal is to have legal and institutional frameworks in place before the exploitation of any hydrocarbon resources begins in Somaliland.
“I assure you , the government of Somaliland shall work with its partners shall embark on a major public awareness and engagement with the community and to establish a security protective force to protect to ensure the safety of expatriates while executing their operation before any major operation begins in earnest”, the Energy Minister stated.
The Minister of Interior Hon Mohamed Ali Warancade addressing the forum participants
The Minister of Interior Hon Mohamed Ali Warancade addressing the forum participants said , “The creation of the OPU became imperative given the need of peaceful security and stability around and at the locales of operations as per international norm given the monumental costs of inputs and expected
outputs. The President who is the Commander in Chief of all security armed forces has the prerogative to create, if need be, any security arm or divisional department.
“Given the fact that the administration has stepped up the efforts and in essence, prioritized the subjective unveiling and objective availing of the natural resources, such that the sector may be gainfully developed and justifiably guarded”, He said.
Oil & Gas
Due to its political status as an unrecognized de facto state and due to the security concerns that oil companies have about operating in the Horn of Africa region, it has been challenging for Somaliland to attract oil companies except for a few that have the risk tolerance for operating in such an environment and have experience in operating in similar challenging areas.
Therefore due to the limited interest from international oil companies to come to Somaliland, the Somaliland government abandoned the bid round process for licensing blocks in favor of an open door policy to solicit and negotiate one-on-one with each oil company that is willing to come here. I understand that when the minister before me in the previous government put out an international bid round for some of the Somaliland blocks nobody came and there were zero bids received which was quite embarrassing
Once we find an interested company, we qualify their technical and financial capacity to farm-in into existing interest or enter into a new Production Sharing Agreement (PSA) with Somaliland by filling out a standard application and submits it to the Ministry of Energy & Minerals (MOEM). Once they qualify, we then enter into negotiations with them to hammer out an agreement. In ensuring that the government gets the best possible stake in these agreement, we hire reputable international oil & gas lawyers to support the government in these negotiations.
Once an agreement is reached with an oil company, the unapproved PSA for awarding new acreage goes to the full council of Minsters chaired by the President and Vice-President to be debated and ratified before the MOEM executes the agreement. In line with our constitution, Somaliland uses an existing Petroleum Act that it inherited from the previous Somali government before the breakup until we draft our own which we are in the process of doing and will be discussed today.
This existing petroleum law vests the approval of such petroleum agreements to the executive branch of our government. But the legislature has the prerogative to summon the Minister of Energy & Minerals, as they often do, to answer any questions posed by them on any PSA agreement that is entered into by the executive branch.
The Ministry of Energy & Minerals has been working for over a year in developing a new upstream petroleum regulatory framework drafted with the help of a world class Norwegian law firm. The development and drafting of this new legal framework was presented in a workshop to Somaliland government key stakeholders this past June. The attorneys then finalized the package incorporating the workshop input in August. The new petroleum regulatory package has been under translation by a Somaliland law firm (Xaqdoon) and has been under review by the Government Solicitor General to ensure it does not conflict with existing Somaliland laws.
Once the translation and review is completed, the bills will be sent to the full Council of Ministers for debate then will be forwarded to the legislature to make it into law. The package consists of a Petroleum Policy, an Upstream Petroleum Bill and a Petroleum Revenue Bill. We are targeting to have the new law passed by the Legislature as early as possible in 2015.
Using an open door policy to attract willing companies to work here versus the bid round has proved more successful for us and we were able to farm-in several companies into existing licenses that we inherited from the previous government and we were also able to sign two PSAs with two new oil companies. Companies that farmed-in into the existing licenses included Jacka Resources, Genel Energy, Rak Gas, Sterling Energy and Petrogas. . I have heard some statements in the media that we entered into not less than 200 new contracts during our tenure. That statement is off by two zeros. The only new PSAs that this government have signed during its 4 ½ year tenure are only two, one with DNO and the other with Ansan
Companies that farmed into existing PSAs such as Genel, Rak Gas and others didn’t have to pay any signing bonuses to the government as per standard industry price and as per the existing PSAs terms. The only companies that paid signature bonuses to the government are as follows:
- Ophir Energy for being awarded ½ a block in 2012 (block SL 9 west)
- DNO for being awarded block 18 in 2012
- Ansan for being awarded 2 ½ blocks in 2013 (portion of SL 7, SL 14 and SL 19)
The signature bonuses pertaining to awarding the above-noted blocks were paid to the Somaliland government. In order to ensure transparency and proper accountability, all funds paid by the oil companies to meet their obligations are sent to the Central Bank of Somaliland who verifies and clears the funds and ensures that they are deposited in proper government treasury accounts. The Ministry of Energy & Minerals have made it a practice to make the receipt of these funds public and the Ministry of Finance have attested to their receipt.
Revenue Generated by the Ministry to the Treasury in 4 ½ years
- The Ministry under the previous government during its 8 years tenure: $185,000
- This government during 4 ½ years: $4.5M
The previous government signed much more PSAs and mineral permits than we did. Yet we generated 24 times as much revenue for the Treasury than they did. If there has been some corruption in our dealings with the oil and mining companies as some unscrupulous tabloid local media outlet with ulterior motives alleged at one time, this Ministry’s record speaks for itself.
Demystifying the Much Misunderstood PSCs
Non-renewable natural resources are an important issue for every country. Countries strive to get the most value for these resources and to exchange the right to develop them for meaningful contributions for the nation and its people. We have done the same here.
Not everyone will be familiar with the structure of a typical “profit sharing contract” or “PSC” – it is an agreement unique and common to the hydrocarbon industry. In a PSC, the investor, like IOCs in Somaliland such as Genel, DNO. RakGas & Ansan, funds all the costs and takes all the risk that it will to find hydrocarbons in commercial quantities. Typically, the chances of making a commercial discovery are 5% to 10% – so there is a significant risk of investing a lot of money and coming away with nothing.
In Somaliland, it is difficult to estimate the chances of success because we are just developing a modern hydrocarbon industry and there is no scientific data to help us predict the existence and location of commercial quantities of hydrocarbons. This means that our commercial terms must be more attractive than in countries that have significant proven hydrocarbon reserves – like Saudi Arabia and the UAE – Abu Dhabi. There are other risks that influence the commercial terms that we can negotiate with investors, including political and legal risk.
A PSC is typically split into a short “exploration period” and a longer and contingent “development period”. If the investor does not make a commercial discovery during the exploration period, the PSC will terminate; the investor will lose all of its rights, including any right to recover its sunk costs; and the government will be free to enter into a new PSC with a new investor. If the investor makes a commercial discovery, a development period will be granted. The development period allows the discovery to be developed and provides an opportunity for the investment costs to be recovered.
If the parties enter the development period, any hydrocarbons produced are allocated between the government and the investor. The government first gets a royalty. The remaining hydrocarbons are divided into two groups – “cost oil” and “profit oil”. The cost oil is available to the investor to recover the money that it has invested in developing the discovery. The profit oil is divided between the government and the investor, with the government getting the larger share. The names “cost oil” and “profit oil” are only convenient labels.
Under a full economic analysis you would see that the investor does not make any profits until it recovers all its sunk costs, which takes years of consistent production. The government gets both the royalty share and its profit oil share regardless of the profitability of the development and without having to invest or risk any money. The investor takes the risks of finding enough hydrocarbons to cover its costs and the future market price of those hydrocarbons.
The terms of the PSC with the IOCs are confidential. If the government improperly discloses these terms, it will be in breach of contract. These terms are kept confidential for many reasons, including protecting the government’s ability to negotiate competitive terms with other investors. Without giving away any particular contract specifics, I can confirm that the new PSC that we signed generally include the following elements, all of which are collectively referred to as the “government take” in the industry:
- The investor pays the government a bonus at the time the contract is signed which is commonly known as signature bonus (we have made public – list all the revenue that we generated).
- The investor pays the government certain bonuses based on achieving certain production milestones (such as X million at X production level is reached – give examples).
- The investor pays the government “surface rent” based on the size of the surface area and the stage of operations.
- The investor funds training and other nation-building programs.
- The investor commits to a conducting a minimum amount of work in the exploration period.
- The government gets the royalty share of hydrocarbons in priority to other allocations.
- The government gets a larger share of the profit oil. This share increases as production milestones are achieved.
The level of government take and revenues that can be obtained should be competitive with other available international opportunities. At the same time, the economic terms should encourage investors to achieve the highest efficient rate of production.
As implied here, risk and reward must be in balance – the lower the technical and other risks in the host country, the higher the government take can be. For example, you would expect that the government of Abu Dhabi will get a very large government take in the bids for their giant discovered onshore fields.
The Much talked about “Resource Curse”
The extractive industry critics are quick to point out that oil resources exploitation often result in environmental disasters and few insiders lining up their pockets on the riches gained from oil production. Although there has been cases of gross resource mismanagement, that is not necessarily the rule but the exception. You have shining examples such Norway which has managed its resources in a fiscally and environmentally responsible way. They have now accumulated nearly $900B sovereign wealth fund for their future generations, which has surpassed that of Abu Dhabi.
African countries such as Ghana are getting better in managing their resources as well and following the Norwegian example. I was recently in the DRC, a post conflict country of immense natural resources who has been looted in the past by everyone. But with improved peace and stability are now getting better handle in managing their resources and have even passed the EITI clearance. By the way we are also aspiring to one day get such clearance with the passage of new regulatory frameworks and improved best practices.
On the other end there is the example of the past misdeeds of the oil industry such as what happened in the Niger Delta. Oil companies can no longer afford to work with governments with corruptive practices or commit environmental disasters. It is bad for their bottom line. It can bankrupt them because of the potential huge liabilities that can result from such offenses. BP almost got bankrupt because of the US Gulf Coast incident. We have included in all our PSCs anti-bribery clauses for the oil and mining companies to abide by, that could result in terminating their contract if found in violation.
Before we get anything out of the ground in Somaliland, we want to emulate the successes of countries that managed their resources well and avoid the mistakes that others have made in exploiting their resources. That is why we hired a Norwegian law firm to draft our Petroleum legal framework to set a sound foundation to our resource management practices. We want to chart the path of implementing best practices.
More often the not, countries that exploited their natural resources have seen their economies grow, new modern infrastructure built and poverty alleviated. We want to chart the path of prudent management of our natural resources to bring about a positive impact on the lives of our people and our economy.
We don’t feel that oil exploitation will bring about conflict in the region, but believe the opposite. It will bring about more stability to Somaliland by growing the economy and alleviating poverty.
Mineral Exploration & Exploitation
- Somaliland is part of the Mozambique belt which is rich in both base and precious metals. It is also part of the Nubian shied which is prospective for gold.
- The minerals potential of Somaliland is under explored. It is what the extractive industry calls “green fields” – meaning unexplored, nothing is proven.
- Attracting mining companies to invest in green fields is tough in the best of times. In recent years, the world commodity prices were declining or remained flat.
- I attended international mining conferences such African Mining Indaba and Africa Downunder to woo mining companies to come to SL.
- We have had limited success so far because of the political and legal risk envisioned by international mining companies in investing in an un-recognized country that is located in a tough neighborhood.
- Issued prospective licenses to several small or start-up companies who have been actively exploring.
- One license has proven a resource that can be commercially exploited and some others are hopeful to do so.
- Like we did with the petroleum sector, we have developed a new mining code as well, which went thru the same process as the new petroleum legal framework package. It will also be soon sent to the Council of Ministers and from there to the Legislature to have a new mining code for Somaliland as well
- Being born in the countryside, in the Saraar Region of Somaliland to a nomadic family, I am country boy at heart and care very much for our indigenous way of life.
- On the other hand, being a petroleum engineer who obtained his education and professional training in the States, a country that has strict environmental regulation. I am keenly cognizant of the need to protect our country’s natural environment from the effects of resource extraction.
- Having lived in California for nearly 25 years, a State known for its beautiful beaches and care for the environment, I am tree hugger myself and no environmental mismanagement will happen under my watch in this country.
- My motto in exploiting our natural resources to improve the economy is first do no harm to the environment
- We are by in large nomadic folks that live off the land through what it provided in the way of pasture for our livestock that our economy depends on. So we have to protect it.
- On both petroleum as well as the mining agreements, we have implemented strict best practices approach in protecting the environment from extractive operations potential adverse effects.
- We require all extractive activities to be preceded by a thorough environmental impact assessment studies performed by reputable international companies. Such is the case on all the PSC that we have signed with the oil companies and the mining agreements as well
- Once an EIA is done, it provides best practices approach to the exploration and the exploitation process and provides clear guidelines for the operators to follow to mitigate any adverse environmental impacts that can result from these operations.
- We work closely with our Ministry of Environment & Rural Development in ensuring jointly with the Ministry of Energy & Minerals proper environmental oversight when operations begin.
This Ministry has achieved in 4 ½ years what was not achieved in the 19 years prior since Somaliland gained its independence.
- We have put Somaliland on the map as an extractive industry destination
- We have taken Somaliland’s name to international oil & gas and mining arenas that it has never been to before
- Despite our lack of recognition, we were able to attract four (4) international oil & gas companies some of which are publicly traded companies to operate in Somaliland. The seismic exploration work is now pending the establishment of an OPU to provide security to these operations. The MoI, Mr. Ali Waran’ade, who is with us here today, will clarify the OPU matter which is also widely misunderstood.
- We are well on our way to begin our first commercial mining operation in Somaliland’s history.
- And we have set the stage for Somaliland to make an oil discovery in the coming few years.
Under the leadership of President Ahmed Mohamed Silanyo, Somaliland is closer than it has ever been in its history to exploit its natural resources for the benefit of its people in a fiscally and environmentally responsible way. In envisioning to develop new modern regulatory framework to guide the sector before anything gets out of the ground, we have assured the Somaliland people that our resources once exploited will be properly managed to avoid the preverbal “resource curse”.
If Somaliland is to become a stable prosperous country in the Horn of Africa that collaborates with the international community to contribute to the peace and stability of the region, I urge the international community to support Somaliland in its peaceful effort to exploit its natural resources for the benefit of its citizens who deserve to aspire for a better standard of living and improved economic conditions.
Likewise, I urge our Somaliland citizens to support this Ministry and the government in its efforts to develop our natural resources that God endowed us with for the common good. We urge our citizens to be patient in realizing our dream as a nation to become a country that benefits economically from its natural resources and not one that keeps it in the ground while we starve on top of it or squanders it when it gets exploited.