Rating all of the Premier League’s summer signings so far this transfer window


The transfer window burst into life this week, with some of the most significant deals in Premier League history being struck, stirring excitement levels amongst supporters ahead of the big kick off.

In case you missed it last time out, we’re aiming to rank every permanent transfer done by teams in English football’s top flight this summer and after so many stellar deals, the upper echelons of our index have been given a major facelift.

So here is the last as it stands currently and a closer examination into the thinking behind the ratings of the most impressive deals done over the last seven days.

  1. Petr Cech – Arsenal: 27/30
  2. Morgan Schneiderlin – Manchester United: 27/30
  3. Yohan Cabaye – Crystal Palace: 26/30
  4. Nathaniel Clyne – Liverpool: 26/30
  5. Toby Alderweireld – Tottenham Hotspur: 25/30
  6. Gerard Deulofeu – Everton: 25/30
  7. Memphis Depay – Manchester United: 25/30
  8. Roberto Firmino – Liverpool: 25/30
  9. James Milner – Liverpool: 25/30
  10. Bastian Schweinsteiger – Manchester United: 25/30
  11. Raheem Sterling – Manchester City: 25/30
  12. Andre Ayew – Swansea City: 24/30
  13. Danny Ings – Liverpool: 24/30
  14. Tyrone Mings – Bournemouth: 24/30
  15. Cedric Soares – Southampton: 24/30
  16. Giorginio Wijnaldum – Newcastle: 24/30

Players on same score are listed alphabetically. For the full set of rankings, click here.

New Entries

=1. Morgan Schneiderlin – Manchester United MS 600x416 Rating all of the Premier League’s summer signings so far this transfer windowFor Manchester United manager Louis van Gaal, Morgan Schneiderlin could be the most important acquisition in his tenure at Old Trafford. The former Southampton man represents tremendous value for money at £25 million and possesses all the attributes needed to tie things together at the heart of this Red Devils midfield.

Whether it’s tackling, passing, winning headers or carrying the ball forward, the Frenchman can do it all. During his time on the south coast he has developed into arguably the most complete central midfield player in the Premier League and can be the heartbeat of a Red Devils side which starts pushing for major honors once again.

=3. Yohan Cabaye – Crystal PalaceCabaye 600x374 Rating all of the Premier League’s summer signings so far this transfer windowCrystal Palace manager Alan Pardew has pulled off an extraordinary coup in bringing Yohan Cabaye from Paris Saint-Germain to Selhurst Park. The Frenchman is a wonderful midfield player to watch, capable of operating in various roles and is someone that has flourished under the tutelage of the Eagles boss previously.

At times last season Palace thrilled us with their blistering counter attacks, but they were crying out for a player with the guile to unlock sides who won’t give them that luxury. Cabaye can add the spark this team needs, giving the Londoners’ attacking options an increasingly formidable feel. For Palace, it’s a major statement purchase.

=5. Toby Alderweireld – TottenhamTA 600x399 Rating all of the Premier League’s summer signings so far this transfer windowDespite a controversial tussle between Spurs and Saints to land Toby Alderweireld, the Belgian will join up with Mauricio Pochettino’s team at White Hart Lane next season, bringing plenty to a back four which looked a little ropey in the 2014-15 term.

The former Southampton man is the perfect defender for the Argentine’s high-octane style and having excelled with Saints on loan last season, is well acquainted with the Premier League. Expect Alderweireld to slot in nicely along compatriot Jan Vertonghen and forge some long overdue solid foundations at the base of this Spurs team.

=5. Bastian Schweinsteiger – Manchester UnitedBS 600x399 Rating all of the Premier League’s summer signings so far this transfer windowBastian Schweinsteiger is the most high profile player to join a Premier League side this summer and Manchester United supporters must be itching to get a look at the former Bayern Munich man at the heart of their midfield.

Although Schweinsteiger is a little past his peak and struggled for minutes recently due to a succession of injuries, at his best he remains a world-class performer; alongside Schneiderlin, the pair could assemble a stunning nexus for the Red Devils. His intangible attributes—a steely determination, winning mentality and incomparable experience—will also play a massive role at Old Trafford.

=5. Raheem Sterling – Manchester Cityraheem sterling1 Rating all of the Premier League’s summer signings so far this transfer windowAfter weeks of unsavory stories, Raheem Sterling has finally completed his move from Liverpool to Manchester City for £49 million and it’s a deal which both teams will be delighted to have finalized.

It’s a lot of money, but Manuel Pellegrini has bought a player who will add a refreshed dimension to his side’s attack, someone who will afford City’s other world-class talents more space to operate in and a youngster who has the talent to become one of the very best in the game. If he sees out the duration of his five-year deal with the club, Sterling will be well worth the outlay.

=12. Georginio Wijnaldum – Newcastle UnitedGW 600x337 Rating all of the Premier League’s summer signings so far this transfer windowAfter a desperate end to the 2014-15 season, Newcastle needed to bring in an exciting signing to get a disillusioned fanbase back on side. In Georginio Wijnaldum, the Magpies have certainly done that and new manager Steve McClaren deserves great credit for luring the Dutch international to St James’ Park.

While Memphis Depay was the man who scored the goals which pushed PSV Eindhoven to the Eredivisie title last season, Wijnaldum was a driving force in the middle of the park. He’s technically gifted, energetic and has an eye for goal too; if he can settle at Newcastle, the Oranje star will be a major asset to the Toon Army and the Premier League.

World Soccer Talk


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here